How to Choose a Bike

387 reviews with an average rating of 4.25 out of 5 stars
A cyclist riding in an urban setting

Looking for a new ride? Sometimes the jargon can be a little intimidating. The good news is that you don’t have to become fluent in bike speak to decide which bike is best for your two-wheeled adventures.

The bike-buying process can be boiled down to three basic steps: 

  1. Figure out your bike type: The right bike for you will depend on where and how you plan to ride. We give you a rundown of bike categories to help you narrow your choices.
  2. Factor in performance and cost: Bikes within a given category and price range generally have similar types of components. But expect to pay more for higher-performance components or frame materials such as carbon.
  3. Make sure your bike fits: Bikes come in a range of sizes, so start by finding the right frame size based on your height. Read more about Bike Fitting Basics. Cycle shops (like REI Co-op’s) can help you fine-tune fit issues that arise after that.
 

Shop Bikes 

 

Figure Out Your Bike Type

A cyclist rides a bike across a bridge in a wooded area

Start by asking yourself where you plan to ride: on streets, bike paths, unpaved roads and trails or some combination of those places? Below is a simple chart with basic bike category options based on the surface(s) each is built for:

 

Riding Surfaces

Bike Types

Paved roads and bike paths

Road bikeshybrid bikes and electric bikes 

Pavement (from pristine to potholed) and natural surfaces

Hybrid bikes and electric bikes

All-road riding (from asphalt to outback)

Gravel and touring bikes

Dirt roads and trails

Mountain bikes and electric bikes

 
Pretty much any bike can handle pavement, of course, and many bikes can be ridden on multiple surfaces. Narrow your choice based on where you expect to do the majority of your riding. You can also check out our more thorough rundown of bike categories below.
 

There’s an Electric Bike for That, Too

Many bike types now include electric bike options, so take a few minutes to decide if an e-bike makes sense for you. Generally, an e-bike with a pedal-assist motor will greatly expand your riding possibilities. While these bikes come with a higher price tag, they allow you to zip up hills with less effort, as well as ride farther and faster. To learn more, read Intro to Electric Bikes.

 

Road Bikes

A cyclist riding a road bike

Road bikes are good for fitness riding, commuting, event rides, touring and racing. Most have a drop-bar handlebar (curling down and toward the rear of the bike), which puts the rider in an aerodynamic position. This bent-forward riding posture can take a little getting used to.

Shop Road Bikes

 

Road bikes come in the following categories, including several electric-bike models:

 

Endurance bikes: “Enduring comfort” might be a more apt name because these road bikes feature a relaxed geometry that helps keep you more comfortable on longer rides. Slightly wider tires give endurance bikes traction on a variety of surfaces, and the tires can be ridden at a lower pressure for a more forgiving ride.

Shop Endurance Bikes

 

Gravel bikes: Because cyclists have always pushed the envelope on where they can ride, multi-surface bikes have been a thing for years. Hybrid bikes (discussed below) are one option. Gravel bikes are an ideal choice, though, if you’re itching to go a little faster and farther. Descended from cyclocross (now a class of elite all-terrain racing bikes), gravel bikes feature a drop handlebar for aerodynamic efficiency, along with wider tires for a forgiving ride and traction on terrain ranging from asphalt to gravel to dirt.

Shop Gravel Bikes 

 

A road touring bike with mountains and a lake in the background

Touring bikes: Touring bikes differ from traditional road bikes in that they are built for riding loaded up with gear over long distances. They have sturdy frames to support heavy loads and have attachment points that let you add racks, fenders, water bottles, pumps, lights and more. A long wheelbase (the distance between the wheel hubs) helps make them easier to control when you have a heavy load.

Shop Touring Bikes 

 

Performance bikes: These light and aerodynamic bikes are built for going fast on the flats and charging up hills during group rides with friends, or for riding in organized races.

Shop Performance Bikes 

Learn more by reading Road Bikes: How to Choose.

 

Mountain Bikes

Three mountain bikers ride on a rocky trail in the southwest

Designed with shock-absorbing features and sturdy builds, mountain bikes can handle dirt trails and the rocks, roots, bumps and ruts that make them so fun. Mountain bikes have lower gears than road bikes so you can ride up steeper terrain.

Two frequently used terms are “full suspension,” meaning a bike has both front and rear suspension, and “hardtail,” meaning a bike has only a suspension fork. Full-suspension models tend to be more expensive, but they offer better traction and a more comfortable ride. They can also handle more varied terrain.

Shop Mountain Bikes

 

Mountain bikes come in the following styles, including several electric-bike models:

 

Cross-country bikes: Lightweight and responsive, this style of mountain bike originated in the racing world, so it delivers both riding speed and climbing prowess. It’s a good choice if you want to ride off road on your fitness rides or if you want a nimbler bike for less-technical local trails.

Shop Cross-Country Mountain Bikes 

 

A trail mountain bike leaning against a rock

Trail bikes: This is the style most new mountain bikers will get. If social trail riding with friends on beginner-friendly trails and dirt roads is your goal, then this is your bike. Bikes in this category place equal emphasis on fun and efficiency.

Shop Trail Bikes 

 

All-mountain bikes: These bikes are a good option as you progress to riding on more technical terrain. All-mountain bikes are well-rounded performers: joyful on steep and flowing descents, while also being capable climbers. Their geometry balances the need for both uphill power and downhill stability, so all-mountain bikes can handle a variety of technical features along the trail.

Shop All-Mountain Bikes 

 

A woman rides a fat bike across a snowy field

Fat-tire bikes: Recognizable because of their oversize tires, these bikes offer outsize traction that makes it possible for you to ride them on sand or snow. The ultra-wide tires are also reassuringly forgiving on all sorts of rough terrain.

Shop Fat-Tire Bikes 

Learn more by reading Mountain Bikes: How to Choose.

 

Hybrid/Fitness Bikes

A cyclist riding a hybrid bike on an overpass with a mural painted in the background

If you want something that performs well on the street but can also handle some unpaved terrain, this is your bike. You might also see hybrid bikes referred to as "fitness bikes" because their comfort and versatility appeal to riders motivated primarily by the exercise benefits of riding. Hybrid bikes generally have a more upright riding position than their road bike counterparts. Most have large-diameter road wheels for speed, paired with wider tires for off-road traction.

A tipoff to whether a bike is more for street riding is the absence of suspension. Hybrid bikes with front suspension are a good choice if you plan to spend more time off road—the tradeoff is a bit more weight and a little less speed in exchange for a cushier ride.

Shop Hybrid Bikes 

Learn more by reading Hybrid Bikes: How to Choose.

 

Specialty Bikes

You can also choose a bike that doesn’t fit neatly into one of the other broad categories above:

An electric cruiser bike sitting on grass with water in the background

Cruiser bikes: Cruiser bikes are built for leisurely rides around your neighborhood or vacation home. Cruiser bikes feature wider tires for traction and cushioning, a comfortable seat and a relaxed sitting position. They’re fun for short rides on flat, paved surfaces.

Shop Cruiser Bikes 

 

A cyclist riding an electric cargo bike

Cargo bikes: Featuring beefy builds so you can haul lots of gear and handle tons of weight, cargo bikes are ideal for running errands and transporting kids. Neither speedy nor nimble, these are highly utilitarian bikes. Read more on How to Use a Cargo Bike.

Shop Cargo Bikes 

 

A folding bike sits on a concrete wall

Folding bikes: These bikes can be folded up and placed in a carrying bag, which makes them handy for commuters with limited storage space at home or the office. Lightweight, strong and able to be folded up quickly, they’re also a good choice if you want to travel with your bike.

Shop Folding Bikes

 

Factor in Performance and Cost

You don’t have to analyze each technical component on a bike, but certain features and premium components can add to the price. When looking for a bike within your budget, keep in mind the following factors that can cost more:

  • Full suspension, hardtail or no suspension: Full-suspension bikes (front and rear shocks) generally cost more, but also offer a smoother ride and the ability to take on the most rugged trails. Hardtails (front suspension only) still absorb bumps, but do so for a little less. Learn more by reading Bike Suspension Basics.
  • Carbon vs. aluminum: Lightweight carbon frames offer premium performance and ride quality—they also mean a leap in price. In contrast, aluminum-frame bikes can be found at every price point. Learn more by reading Understanding Bike Frame Materials.
  • Going electric: Electric bikes expand the riding horizons for all riders. For help deciding whether the added technology is worth the added investment, read Intro to Electric Bikes.
  • Component quality: A bike’s components—essentially all the major systems other than the frame and wheels—are usually part of a tiered group. As you move up to a higher price in a bike category, the corresponding component group will be more responsively tuned and add to the overall cost of your bike.
 

Gearing

A detail shot of gears on a bicycle

Bikes vary in the number of gears, the range of the gears (lower gears make it easier to pedal) and the available gear ratios. Generally, most models in a given bike category will have similar gearing. That means it’s not something you have to think about unless you really want to. Learn more by reading Bike Gears and Shifting Basics.

 

Wheel Size

Four different bike wheels of differing sizes

Wheel size is another bike feature that’s largely predetermined by the bike category you choose, with one big exception: Most mountain bikes come with either 29" wheels or 27.5” wheels. From a cost standpoint, the difference isn’t significant. So your choice is largely a matter of performance nuances. To learn more read 27.5 vs. 29er: Which Mountain Bike Is Right for Me?

 

Brake Type

In years past, rim brakes were the norm and disc brakes the exception. Disc brakes have always offered superior braking power in all conditions, though, and they now dominate the market because the cost of disc brake technology has come down over the years.

 

A detail shot of rim brakes on a bicycle

Rim brakes, which work by squeezing the brake pads against the sides of the wheel rims, are still an economical option. They make it easy to check brake pad wear and to replace worn pads.

 

A detail shot of disc brakes on a bicycle

Disc Brakes, which feature brake pads that grip onto a brake rotor mounted to the wheel hub, come in two versions:

  • Hydraulic disc brakes offer more progressive and stronger braking with less finger effort, and they self-adjust for brake pad wear.
  • Mechanical disc brakes need manual adjusting as the pads wear.

To learn more about braking systems read What’s the Difference Between Rim Brakes and Disc Brakes?

 

Bike Size and Fit

Getting the right frame size is the first step. Fortunately, most bike manufacturers have size charts that list your frame size based on your height. The most important aspects of bike fit, standover height (the distance between your body and the top tube when you straddle the bike) and reach (the distance from seat to handlebar) can then be fine-tuned with some minor adjustments.

To learn more about how to fit a bike, as well as how to do adjustments at home, read Bike Fitting Basics and Mountain Bike Fitting Basics. Beyond getting the correct frame size, you’ll also need to fuss with nuances like seat height.

REI Co-op stores and other cycling specialty shops will also adjust your bike’s fit, either during a test ride or after you buy a bike. Tell them about any discomfort and they’ll happily address your fit issues. Note, though, that you need to give your body several weeks to get accustomed to your new ride. It’s a little bit like breaking in a new pair of heavy-duty hiking boots.

 

Video: Bicycle Basics

 

 

Related Articles

 


How helpful was this article? Click a star to rate.


Contributing Experts

Paul Hatten

Born in Aotearoa New Zealand, REI’s Paul Hatten was a competitive cyclist and has 20+ years of cycle shop experience. He’s mountain biked in Austria, gravel raced in East Timor, spun through the Alps and bike commuted the streets of Seattle.

Jessica Pray

Jessica is an assistant category merchant on the action sports team at REI headquarters. She loves to do anything outside with friends, especially road cycling and snowboarding. She is a recent transplant to Seattle from Southern California