Every camper, road tripper, tailgater and boater needs a reliable way to keep food and drinks cold, whether they’re headed out for a few hours or a few days. A soggy sandwich, lukewarm seltzer or tepid charcuterie spread can put a damper on an otherwise great outing.
That’s why we had REI Co-op Member Testers from across the country sample top-rated coolers at campgrounds, backyard birthday parties, beach hangouts, barbecues and more. The goal: to test durability, portability, the activities for which each is best suited, and most importantly, whether they’ll keep your seltzer cold and your Caesar salad from wilting. These are the five that performed best.
Test Results
Find quick recommendations below or scroll down for in-depth reviews.
Igloo MaxCold Latitude 54-Quart Cooler [score: 98/100]
YETI Roadie 24 2.0 Hard Cooler [score: 92/100]
Stanley The All Day Julienne Mini Cooler [score: 88/100]
REI Co-op Campwell 18 L Folding Cooler [score: 86/100]
Oyster Tempo Cooler Bundle [score: 85/100]
Jump to Buying Advice or How We Test.
Editor’s note: We transitioned this guide from a staff picks to a tested guide in April 2026 after asking REI Co-op Member testers and staff testers to share their honest opinions about coolers they've used on camping trips, at backyard hangouts and more. They provided real-life feedback about each, and we included the top-scoring ones on this list. Learn more in How We Test.
Test Results at a Glance
Cooler | Type | Capacity | Best for | Score (out of 100) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Hard-sided | 51 liters | Camping, tailgating, barbecues | 98 | |
Hard-sided | 23 liters | Camping, sporting events, road trips | 92 | |
Soft-sided | 7 liters | Picnics, work lunches, short day trips | 88 | |
Soft-sided, foldable | 18 liters | Camping, sporting events, picnics | 86 | |
Hard-sided | 23 liters | Camping, boating, road trips | 85 |
Igloo MaxCold Latitude 54-Quart Cooler
Score 98
Type Hard-sided
Materials Plastic, THERMECOOL foam insulation
Capacity 51 liters
Weight 10 lbs. 9.6 oz.
Best for Camping, tailgating, barbecues
Simple, affordable, reliable: That’s the Igloo MaxCold Latitude 54-Quart Cooler. It may not be bear-proof or have the bells and whistles of more expensive coolers, but among outdoorists and travelers who prefer ease-of-use, functionality and an accessible price point, it gets high marks.
Notably, it offers plenty of room for food, drinks and ice. Testers said it was spacious enough to accommodate everything they needed for multiday camping trips, sometimes with room to spare: It fits up to 76 icy-cold 12-ounce cans. It’s also lightweight and portable, plus testers said they appreciated its durability and insulating power (it can retain ice for up to five days, depending on the outside temp). “[It’s a] great product; I can rely on any of the Igloo products I own,” said Casey, one of two testers in Buffalo, New York.
Features are simple but useful, including four self-draining cup holders in two different sizes in the lid, a grab handle on each side to easily carry the cooler alone or with a friend, and a plug for draining melted ice. A simple latch on the front secures the lid and is easy to open and close.
For those who need a cooler that works well without all the flash, this is an excellent choice.
Bottom Line: A reliable cooler with a roomy interior and an easy-to-use design.
Testing Stats:
- Testing locations: New York
- Testing duration: 127 hours
- Best testing story: “I was getting ready for a trip to a campsite for me and my family to go to. Unfortunately, the trip got canceled after we got everything packed and we were on our way. We got back home to find out our power was out but all the goods we packed for the trip were saved for a few days because of how long the cooler keeps ice.”
YETI Roadie 24 2.0 Hard Cooler
Score 92
Type Hard-sided
Materials Permafrost insulation (polyurethane)
Capacity 23 liters
Weight 13 lbs. 4.8 oz.
Best for Camping, sporting events, road trips
A cushy strap, grippy bottom and leakproof design make the burly Roadie 24 2.0 Hard Cooler from YETI ideal for everything from camping and road trips to all-day sporting events. It offers plenty of room for food, drinks and snacks, yet is compact enough to fit behind the passenger seat of a car. Sturdy latches and rugged construction mean this ice box will withstand years of adventuring. “I feel like this cooler could withstand anything,” said Jacob T., our Pennsylvania-based tester.
The interior is designed to hold up to 33 cans and is tall enough to accommodate most standard wine and two-liter bottles. “I was honestly shocked with how much it could fit,” Jacob reported. Another tester said that using the brand’s reusable ice packs (sold separately) helped to maximize space.
A cold lock gasket in the lid and pressure-injected insulation give the Roadie superior insulating abilities. Testers were wowed by how long it kept its contents chilled in the middle of June. “The cooler was able to keep all of my drinks plus steaks when glamping cold for over a day, and nearly two, with some of the ice still not liquid,” Jacob said. Another found that the Roadie kept food cold for multiple days when stored outside their trailer.
It fit easily in testers’ cars and the cargo wagons that some used to haul gear to bleachers or a campground. While a shoulder strap makes it relatively easy to carry, Jacob noted that, at over 13 pounds, the Roadie is on the heavier side. This isn’t the cooler you’ll want to schlep by hand for a mile to your campsite—consider the REI Co-op Campwell Folding Cooler for that.
Features abound, including exterior tie-downs for use on a boat or truck bed, quick-release latches to make access easy, a drain plug on one side, and multiple add-ons like baskets and organizers (sold separately) to customize the interior. Like the Stanley Julienne, it comes in various colors and larger sizes, including a wheeled version.
Bottom Line: A compact, durable, functional cooler that’s perfect for short camping trips.
Testing Stats:
- Testing locations: Washington, Montana, Idaho, Pennsylvania
- Testing duration: 460+ hours
- Best testing story: “The Roadie was able to keep all of its ice intact on a whole eight-hour day outside camping near the beach. The cooler was in the sun the entire time since there was no shade, but it had no issues going through something like that.”
Stanley The All Day Julienne Mini Cooler - 10 Cans/7.4 Qts.
Score 88
Type Soft-sided
Materials Polyester
Capacity 7 liters
Weight 1 lb. 3.04 oz.
Best for Picnics, work lunches, short day trips
Stanley has become synonymous with functional, colorful products, so it’s no surprise testers loved the compact yet practical All Day Julienne Mini Cooler for short day trips.
Testers reported the Julienne Mini from Stanley kept food cold (or hot) for up to 12 hours, even when it was left in the car, making it perfect for packing lunches and snacks. It’s roomy enough for reusable food storage containers or drinks, though space can start to feel cramped once you add ice packs or ice.
Its petite size (at approximately 9 x 9 x 7 inches, it’s the smallest cooler we tested) and removable shoulder strap make it light and easy to transport to the beach, pool, park or picnic site. A hands-free doctor-bag-style opening with a leakproof zipper offers a wide mouth for easy access. One tester noted the hinged opening was a bit stiff, but functional.
Packing it is a breeze, thanks to a solid bottom and semi-rigid sides, which Kristina V., our tester in Washington, noted were sturdier and easier to use than those on most other soft-sided coolers. “It makes standing up bowls or [an insulated water bottle] a lot easier,” she said.
It’s also easy to clean and holds up to daily life, with our New York–based tester, Kimberly V., commenting that it’s survived multiple drops. All that said, it’s on the pricier side. If you’re looking for a more affordable option for picnics and keeping food cold while at school and work, check out the REI Co-op Campwell 18 L Folding Cooler, which is available in an eight-liter lunch box size. The Stanley Julienne also comes in larger capacities, including a Midi and Max version.
Bottom Line: This colorful cooler is perfect for lunches, picnics and keeping drinks cold for hours, plus it’s durable, functional and fun.
Testing Stats:
- Testing locations: California, Washington, New York
- Testing duration: 120+ hours
- Best testing story: “This is a lovely little cooler that's changed the game for road trip food for me! Long gone are fast food stops; I now cook my meals ahead of time and store them in this cooler!”
REI Co-op Campwell 18 L Folding Cooler
Score 86
Type Soft-sided, foldable
Materials Recycled polyester (bluesign® approved on solid colors only); base and lining
Capacity 18 liters
Weight 1 lb. 2.3 oz.
Best for Camping, sporting events, picnics
Portability and packability are nearly as important as functionality when choosing a cooler. This is where the Campwell 18 L Folding Cooler from REI Co-op shines: It’s easy to transport from your car to your campsite and back again, and it takes up minimal storage space thanks to its collapsible design.
This soft-sided ice chest folds nearly flat when not in use and holds up to 12 cans when expanded. It’s also adjustable: Clip together the wings on the corners to create a space-saving, boxy shape that’s perfect for road trips or unfasten them to carry the cooler as a tote with more room for snacks. Testers loved that versatility. In either configuration, a zipper opening at the top makes it easy to access the contents. You can carry the Campwell cooler by hand or over your shoulder using the tote handles or the removable, padded shoulder strap.
Its compact shape, light weight and insulating power make it perfect for picnics, day trips and short overnights. The Campwell cooler even kept drinks and snacks cold during one tester's eight-hour road trip, despite frequent opening and closing. “This is our go-to cooler for any activity we participate in where we need a cooler,” said John J., our tester in Washington.
Just be careful to keep it upright: John noted water dripping from the zipper when it tipped over with melted ice inside. Another consideration: Its foldable design is tougher to clean and drain compared to coolers with hard, flat interiors. Still, this flexible ice chest is built to last. "We've used several of these in different sizes for many years and haven't had a single issue with any of them," John said. "This is a solid cooler.”
Bottom Line: For ease of use, portability, packability and versatility, this soft-sided cooler is hard to beat.
Testing Stats:
- Testing locations: Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Montana, Wyoming, Arizona
- Testing duration: 140+ hours
- Best testing story: "I got tired of not having a cooler (or having to buy a cheap one) at sporting events out of town, so I packed this as a carry-on to my kids' four-day baseball tournament in Arizona. I could have checked it, too, but it held a lot of things!"
Oyster Tempo Cooler Bundle
Score 85
Type Hard-sided
Materials Wrought and cast aluminum, foamed EVA, nylon
Capacity 23 liters
Weight 12 lbs. 4.8 oz.
Best for Camping, boating, road trips
Designed to work without ice, the space-age Tempo Bundle from Oyster comes with two low-profile ice packs designed to be frozen ahead of time and placed on the bottom of the cooler. The intention: to offer max cooling capacity without having to devote space to bags of ice or bulky ice blocks. That’s because aluminum is more thermally efficient than plastic, so the Oyster cools down faster and stays that way with less ice than plastic coolers.
Testers loved the aesthetics as well as the ease-of-use, starting with the fact that they could open the Oyster from either side or remove the lid completely. “On our friend's tiny boat, it allowed us to access it in a tight space.”
Not having to worry about ice means there’s ample storage space inside the cooler: The 23-liter model we tested holds 36 cans plus two slim ice packs (included). Its roomy interior makes it perfect for all-day excursions or overnight trips. It consistently keeps food and drinks cold for several days. That said, Phuong L., managing editor at REI who tested the Oyster Tempo in Washington, reported that drinks didn’t feel as cold on day two as they might in a cooler filled with ice.
Testers found it uncomfortable to cart the Oyster over longer distances due to a lack of grab handles or padding on the shoulder strap. On the plus side, the absence of heavy ice means it weighs less than many other options when loaded with supplies.
Worth noting: It’s not designed for sitting on, so keep that in mind if you like to use your cooler as a back-up camp stool. The Oyster Tempo excels at short trips and, according to Phuong, is perfect “when you need to BYOB drinks to other people's backyard parties.”
Bottom Line: The Oyster Tempo keeps food and drinks cold for days, all without ice. Its sleek, aluminum construction is also a conversation starter.
Testing Stats:
- Testing locations: Oregon, Washington
- Testing duration: 100 hours
- Best testing story: “The Oyster Tempo was the subject of a lot of interest and debate among my friends at picnics and barbecues. I, like others, liked how sleek and compact it was. It just looked good. An upside: No need to worry about ice and melting water.”
Buying Advice for Coolers
Not sure where to start when buying a new cooler? Keep these things in mind to find the one that’s right for you.

Cooler Construction
Here are the main types of cooler models, plus the pros and cons of each.
Soft-Sided Coolers
As the name suggests, soft-sided coolers like the REI Co-op Campwell 18L Folding Cooler and Stanley The All Day Julienne Mini Cooler feature pliable materials inside and out as opposed to hard plastic or metal. They tend to be lighter and easier to carry than hard-sided options and easier to store when not in use. They also can be less durable and less efficient at keeping contents chilled.
Soft coolers are often best suited for day trips, short excursions, or when you have to carry small amounts over longer distances. They come in all shapes and sizes, but are usually smaller than hard-sided coolers.
Hard-Sided Coolers
Hard-sided coolers like the YETI Roadie 24 2.0 and Oyster Tempo tend to be heavier than their soft-sided counterparts, but they often keep their contents colder for longer and do a better job of protecting what’s inside (especially when tossed in the bed of a truck or checked as luggage). Premium hard-sided coolers usually keep ice frozen for days instead of hours. They frequently come in larger sizes, too, so it's easier to pack more food and drinks for a larger group.
In general, a hard-sided cooler is a solid choice for adventures like car camping, backyard barbecues, tailgating and road trips where you don’t have to carry them very far. They can be heavy and bulky to haul around, so may not be as suitable for activities that involve walking or hiking, but they’re worth choosing for superior insulation and broad functionality.
Backpack Coolers
Backpack coolers are often soft-sided coolers outfitted with shoulder straps for hands-free transport. Some backpack coolers have extra features like external pockets or lash straps so you can take additional gear or accessories with you. They’re a good choice if you plan to carry a cooler for long distances, like on a hike, and want to keep your hands free and weight centered on your back.
Features
Cooler features vary. Depending on your preferences, you may want to look for one with cup holders, tie-down points or add-on interior organizational systems like plastic compartments. Other features, such as molded rulers (handy for measuring fish), are more specific to one chosen activity. The more features a cooler has, the more expensive it's likely to be.
Wheeled Coolers
Some hard-sided coolers roll to make transport easier when they’re fully loaded. Mechanisms vary from small plastic wheels to inflatable tires with all-terrain tread. You can hitch some rolling coolers to your bike with an added accessory.
Electric Coolers
Newer to the market, powered coolers like the Dometic CFX5 55 Powered Cooler use electricity rather than ice to chill the interior, making it easier to keep contents cold. They make it possible to travel with frozen foods. Electric coolers weigh significantly more than traditional hard- or soft-sided coolers and cost a lot more, too.
How We Test
We sent a slew of top-selling and recently launched coolers to REI Co-op Member testers and staffers—like REI Co-op Members Casey in New York and Jacob in Pennsylvania as well as REI Co-op managing editor Phuong in Seattle—and asked them to haul their ice boxes to campgrounds, backyard barbecues, sporting events, boat days and more. They packed work lunches, camp meals, sparkling water, cans of beer and ice cream, among other chilled goodies, all in the name of gear expertise. The five coolers on this list were their overall favorites.


