Bought these for a multi-day tour. Seem nice enough at first glance, on par with some Avenirs I'd also purchased. First time I went to put them on, the straps that hold them on the rack tore off the bag itself (with very little force). Managed to hold them on with some bungees, but a couple of hours later one of the main zippers failed. Sure, they're nice because they're flush with the top of the rack so you can strap more gear on top, but I WOULDN'T TAKE THESE IF THEY WERE FREE!
Was this a gift?:
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend