Love the feel of these flips. Super soft foot bed. The only gripe is that the arch support is not as high as their all rubber counter part. I have really high arches, so it is noticeable. Other than that, these are great. Supremely comfortable, but probably not strong/durable enough to handle my typical adventures. I'll keep the rubber Chaco Flips for the mountains and the leather guys for the city.
Sizing= All rubber: 12. Leather: 11
Feels half size too small
Feels true to width
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend