
This item is currently sold out or unavailable online.
Or, may we suggest shopping for similar items:
This page is provided for reference to historical product information.
Please note: MSR products can only be shipped to U.S. addresses.
Made in USA.
Item 401062
| Specification |
| ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best use |
| ||||
| Weight | |||||
| Dimensions | |||||
| Material(s) |
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
Cons
Best Uses
Reviewed by 7 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-7
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
This product seems to have some very good features, and then some overlooked design flaws, or more fairly, one design flaw.First the good. The construction of the heat exchanger seems to be pretty sturdy, and with few moving parts, hopefully will be reliable for a long time. One reviewer on backcountry.com said that he has had this exchanger for 15 years and it still works well. The design is great for catching the flame of a backpacking stove, especially ones that sit on their canisters since a ground based wind screen is not an option for these.Now the flaw. MSR advertises this product as fitting all 1.5-2L MSR pots with the exception of the Titan 1.5L. I bought this product after purchasing the MSR Base 2 Pot Set and an MSR Pocket Rocket stove. The stove sits on its canister, so as noted above, it will not work with a windscreen unless you want to risk overheating the canister. The Base 2 is 2 pots, one 1.5L and the other 2.5L (neither a Titan 1.5L). The exchanger fits the 2.5 perfectly, but it does not get tight enough to fit the 1.5. Now given that the product is advertised to only work on pots up to 2L, the fact that it works on 2.5L pots is good, but it does not work on 1.5L pots, at least not ones the diameter of the Base 2. I tried contacting MSR about this design flaw, but wasn't able to, so I ended up calling REI and asking them if they could figure it out. After 15 minutes of trying to force it to work, the REI representative agreed that it must be a design flaw because it would not fit. I eventually found that hooking the tightening hook around one of the waffle ridges and tightening the screw will make it work on the 1.5L, but seeing as this costs [$] and is advertised to work on pots in a .5L range, it should have been designed with a hole for 1.5L pots.Conclusions: If you have a stove that will enable you to use a windscreen, I would recommend using that instead. It's cheaper, lighter, and works on all pots. If, however, you cannot use a windscreen I would still say get the exchanger, but wait for a sale as it's not worth [$]. If you're only going to using this for 2-2.5L pots, you should be perfect. If you're thinking about this for a pot less than 2L however, I would look elsewhere or settle for jerry-rigging it.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
I've had the heat exchanger for years now. Usually, I will use it when the weather is acting up, and the wind is blowing significantly.When cooking a larger dish, which requires time and energy - meaning fuel, I will always use it; regardless of season or temperature.It reduces the fuel useage which means carbon / voc emissions. While this will take a little room in your pack, it saves a lot of fuel and time; over the course of a trip or outing.Through the ensuing years, the price has come down significantly for this product, since the R&D has long since been recovered.For those who use isobutane / propane cannisters, this was made in Heaven. Since the cannisters will go longer and farther.The question then will be for some reading this, what about stability? Use the universal cannister base made by MSR and sold at REI and your concerns are over.The heat exchanger, does not compensate for a wind screen, but it does mitigate significantly the loss of temperature, due to winds / ambient temperatures and mositure levels.You've everything to gain, and nothing to lose by purchsing this product.The last comment is that if you are using titanium, which is a poor conducter of heat, this will help increase the effiiciency of the cooking vessel significantly.Personally, having used titanium, I avoid "it" now like the plague.The price of this product currently, makes "it" a wise investment.Enjoy!!
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
This product has been in use for just about 15 years. It has gone several different places and has saved fuel and time each time used. That said setup takes an extra few seconds but water boils faster, food feeds hungry people faster. While I have not done any comparisons with a stop watch I have in the past decided not to use it. After twiddeling my thumbs a little too long decided it will be used every time warm, cold, high or low altitude. Two last items, first as my wife has started going camping with me I've begun the transition to minimalist, as I now carry 1.5x the weight I used to, zero weight would be awesome. With the weight of fuel and less being needed I figure the weight to be a wash making speed the desiding factor. The second, being the main reason for posting this, is the use with an alpine cookset. As was stated in the begining mine is almost 15 years old is used with the alpine 2 cookset(wish this set was available in Ti)and a whisperlie international. When packed right everything fits just fine, even silverware for two, nested into the cookset. You must put in everything just so and while I found that a strap is handy it does not require any type of force to put the lid on. If I remeber, I will take pics and add later.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
In a recent side by side test of several cooking systems the MSR heat exchanger paired with my MSR Whisperlite stove and the large alpine pot plus lid boiled 600 ml of water in 2 minutes 21 seconds. 45° F at Goose Prairie WA. 600ml was used to make it fair as that was the capacity of one of the systems, in this case a titanium cookpot, which by the way did not prove to be very efficient. For winter camping or backpacking trips of more than a few days the fuel savings will pay for the added weight of the MSR heat exchanger. The only drawback IMHO is the bulk of the heat exchanger. With it coiled up in the nestled pots there is no longer room for the stove.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
Works really well. Shortens cooking time which saves fuel. Durable construction. worth the weight and space it takes up.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
Works great. Got mine with my Alpine cookset, well worth the money. Only problem: it takes up the space in my cookset that I use for my stove or MSR Kitchen Cupboard. I take it for cold weather or high altitude, and for my 2 week survival trip every other year. It really cuts down on the fuel usage.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about MSR XPD Heat Exchanger:
Tested 6 stoves/fuels, side by each at ambient temp of 20 degrees. Water was at 40 degrees. Matching MSR pans cooled in snow three minutes between tests. regardless of stove selected, cover and heat exchanger made difference. On the Whisperlite Internationale, for example: An uncovered pot took 6 minutes and thirty seconds to boil; adding a tight lid dropped the boiling time by a minute and a half; fitting it with the heat exchanger and cover reduced the boiling time to just four minutes. The MSR heat exchanger was advertised at 7 oz; ours weighed in at 5.2. Saves 2 oz fuel per pint at 20 degrees. Troop 6 did the test, you do your math. We'll take one every trip.
Displaying reviews 1-7
How are we doing? Give us feedback on this page.
REI Anniversary Sale May 17–27. Plus, members SAVE 20% on 1 full-price item with coupon code ANNV13. Details