Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Welcome REI Co-op Members! We're glad you're here. If you can't access the Co-op Members section of the community, click here for instructions on how to join the section that's just for you.

Re: Kayak purchase basics

I’ve been kayaking (lake, calm ocean) a number of times with rented equipment and I’m looking to make a purchase. Any pointers on what features are worth the investment and which are not? Thanks, Rich

7 Replies

big question which will guide your options, what is your transportation?

Meaning, can you easily transport something solid or do you need the portability of an inflatable?

I've been in both camps.

  • Check around I too am looking for a couple of Kayaks a lot of dealers have spring demo days I already am on the list to demo Hobies and a few other pedal and paddle kayaks

i actually have the pedal kayak, its a Hobie mirage, if you don't mind the cost, they do work nicely

Decide what type of kayaking you plan to enjoy as whitewater kayaks make horrible touring boats and sea kayaks don’t do well in river rapids. 

What’s your preference - Sit on top or a traditional sit in kayak?

answers to these questions will help you navigate your kayak purchase. 

@rdavino2000 -

Nice answers already. Essentially figure out your use-case, budget and transportation. There is lot more stuff already out there, e.g. please checkout 

Some other considerations from our time researching our purchase:

  • TCO (total cost of ownership) will include a paddle (or two if different sized family members will be paddling), life jacket or PFD, possible registration fee  in your state, flotation bags if you buy a sit-in without bulk heads, and any other safety gear required by your state. Oh yeah, rooftop carrier too
  • We looked at both a sit inside as well as a sit on top and the one overriding "need" we looked at was good tracking. One kayak we rented last year couldn't keep a straight line no matter how I paddled. It was so frustrating. The sit on top that we decided upon has excellent reviews for that
  • Do you have adequate storage space if you're not getting an inflatable?
  • One of the things that I kept reading and hearing in everything is the importance of a good paddle. Several sites and channels all said that you'd be happier with your kayak purchase if you bought a slightly lower-level model and spent the extra money on a better paddle.

Good luck! We're excited about getting ours this year, too.

“Between every two pine trees there is a door leading to a new way of life.” (John Muir)

Superusers do not speak on behalf of REI and may have received
one or more gifts or other benefits from the co-op.

First decide on what you want to do with it. As was stated, a WW boat would be terrible for a 5 day trip, and a sea kayak doesnt take class 3 real well (ask me how I know 🙂 but my stuff was still dry )

If you want to float for 5 miles on a Saturday afternoon on a slow river, any flat bottom rounded big box play boat will work. Sit in kayak, or sit on top (sink sot)  It will be light for loading and cover everything you do. Unless..

If you want to play in rolling water and flip through rocks, then a WW boat and some learning are for you. 

If you want to do that same river, for 100 miles, then you need to look at a sea/touring boat. They are heavier, longer (figure 14-18'), and you wear them like a pair of pants. They have rudders, skegs, rigging, and fore and aft chambers that are watertight so it wont sink. Watch the weight, you are going to carry gear. Some say they are "tippy" not really, takes a bit to get used to and exercise that keeps the hips loose.

If you want to play in the ocean, then for safety, you need to be in a boat with bulkheads and air chambers, or at least a aft bulkhead and a air bag. Sea or touring.

Pond lakes fishing slow water, then the pedal boats or a flat wide sit on top make life nice, but they are heavy.

Some SOT boats are built so that you could do at least weekend camping and are easier to remount if you go over. The boat already has holes in it for the water to drain out, and you dont have to worry about it sinking. You can mount your gear to the boat and head out.