Thanks Phil! I get all that, but I was on a hike a few weeks ago with a friend and she rolled her ankle stepping on a rock and was put on the shelf for a week. For me, if I don't plan on stepping in any mud or if the terrain is a well worn trail, I go with trail runners or something like chacos, but I don't like wet socks and I'm overly cautious fearing ankle rolling. It's been snowy here lately as well and it sucks to submerge your foot in cold wet slushy mud without boots. I'm going to cue the the @REI guys right here to link us to their article on the great debate between boots vs trail runners, haha. Anyway, with the kids, they're ages 5 and 7, both boys. We have a baby too, but he goes in the carrier for now. The concern for the boys is different... they can do a lot worse damage to themselves than rolling and ankle so ankle support is the concern for the adults, whereas for the kids I'm just looking for something that won't hurt if they stub their toe, offers some level of water resistance and is comfortable for them when they're both walking and climbing things like trees and rocks. Also the typical kid's shoe we buy wears out pretty quickly and I'm hopeful to find a boot that has potential to live through multiple kids. In any case, thanks to all for the feedback. I definitely agree, the in store consult is the way to go. I did that for my own boots before a thru hike a few years ago and I still love my Asolos. I generally know a little bit about boots, but I'm looking to really walk into the store with as much knowledge as possible to minimize my time in there... both for safety reasons in the current situation, but also because 3 boys in an REI store for more than 20 or 30 minutes usually ends up with someone getting stuck in a display tent, losing a kid in the clothing racks, or breaking up a wrestling match on the sleeping pads. Either way, thanks to all for your help. The how to buy a boot articles are pretty solid and while I probably won't go the trail runner route for myself, it's great food for thought, especially for the kids. Cheers! - Mike Cheers! - Mike
... View more