I have the Vasque Saga, which in my opinion is the best boot. I know that this is not the boot options you listed, but I would encourage you to check it out! It is a high rise boot, with lots of support. I have them in women's. 

I use the boot for day hiking, camping, longer hikes that are 8-10 miles at a time, and will be using them on my trip to Acadia in August. The reviews for the boot say that the shoelaces are thin and break, but I have had mine for about a year and have had no such problem! I would suggest bringing extra shoelaces, regardless as they are good to have as back up. 

My biggest advice would be to try on ANY boot you are thinking about purchasing, as every foot is different!

Hope this helped!