@John you've got a niche request here, as the majority of full-leather boots will be waterproof, either by nature of the leather and/or by the addition of a waterproof liner (either GTX, Event or a proprietary material)! Also, it's helpful to know a bit about your feet because each vendor fits a bit differently - wide/narrow/medium width? High/low/medium arch? Any tricky spots, like bunions? 

Without knowing these details, we'll make a few general recommendations, then always encourage either an REI store visit or virtual outfitting appointment:

We hope this helps get you started, and we'll be interested to hear what other community members suggest!

At REI, we believe time outside is fundamental to a life well lived.