@pzero7 tough choice for sure! One thing to double check, if it's a big factor is your decision making, is the reference you made to the warranties. At quick glance, both the Big Agnes and MSR warranties similarly cover defects in workmanship and manufacturing but not wear and tear or damage due to accidents; we also didn't see a reference to a lifetime warranty from Big Agnes. We just wanted to make sure you were really clear on what those warranties do/don't cover if that's an important factor in your decision!

At REI, we believe time outside is fundamental to a life well lived.