I've tried about 2 different kinds with no luck. My most recent purchase was the Schmidt's and I LOVE it!
I got the "Waves" scent and it smells like the beach! I can't wait to try all their other scents out.
+1 for Schmidt’s Charcoal+Magnesium Deoderant.
Tom’s didn’t work for me. Before finding Schmidt’s, I used Arm and Hammer, but I would start to slightly stink at the end of a day of outdoor activities. With Schmidt’s, I smell great no matter how much I sweat or how active I am.
I use Meow Meow Tweet (hilarious name, I know). The issue I have is that I get a reaction to baking soda and/or charcoal. This one is pretty good and the grapefruit smells nice.
I got a reaction/irritation from the baking soda in Schmidt's Naturals. Thankfully, they make a sensitive skin formula...and I love the woodsy scents!
Glacial-fed stream seems to do the trick for me - cold, invigorating, manly.