cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Welcome REI Co-op Members! We're glad you're here. If you can't access the Co-op Members section of the community, click here for instructions on how to join the section that's just for you.

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

So I am a fan of ultra-light and compact backpacking for multiday excursions. I have used the MSR PocketRocket for a pretty long time now. It used to fit inside some lightweight aluminum pots I had, then I switch to the Sea to Summit X-pot and kettle which the cups and bowls nest inside of.

I've always wondered about the Jetboil systems, but they are HUGE in comparison to the gear I normally carry. I know they are super fast and more efficient with fuel, but is the extra space really worth it for a few minutes of cook time and a few grams of fuel? The equipment I have already worked incredibly fast as it is, I'm not even sure I would want it to cook or boil any faster.

I do want to try the system, but I really feel I would never carry it anywhere. Just looking for some insight and personal options/experiences with the Jetboil systems.

-Cyrus
0 Likes
Reply
23 Replies

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@speakingquitefrankly thanks for the info on the new system... it actually does look great!

 

I am considering purchasing the Jetboil Ceramic Cook Pot at the moment which looks very similar, with the addition of a cozy and an additional 0.7L in size. But weighing only 10oz and with a 2 minute boil time, at only $65 on REI... I think it might be time to try something new. 

-Cyrus
0 Likes
Reply

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

to be completely honest, I've used this stove: https://amzn.to/3slXB4o for years with a variety of lightweight pots. It works just fine for me- just have to balance it better than a jet

0 Likes
Reply

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

That's great! I actually had one of those stoves too about 7-8 years back. It worked pretty great.

-Cyrus
0 Likes
Reply

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

I have a Primus Express (pretty similar to your Pocket Rocket).

I used it in conjunction with a titanium mug on a Colorado Trail thru hike. One 8 oz canister lasted me just over half the hike (about 3 weeks). I kept the flame level relatively low, so that the flame was directed only onto the bottom of the mug, but didn't come up around the edges of thebottom of the titanium mug. I like the flexibility of being able to choose the stove and cook pot separately, which you lose with the JetBoil system. I think that stove type like the Pocket Rocket is just about optimum for long treks.

I would consider a Jet Boil if I were frequently going out in more extreme windy conditions, or on a shorter trip where the weight and bulk are less critical.

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@scottmc thanks for that insight! Really good information here, I love it!

-Cyrus
0 Likes
Reply

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

I have the PocketRocket and didn't really consider JetBoil systems until we backpacked with someone who used a JetBoil next to us while we cooked with our PocketRocket. For fun we sourced water from the same MSR camp bladder, so our water and outdoor temperature conditions were identical. When we used identical measured volumes and her JetBoil consistently and impressively beat our PocketRocket in boil times. At breakfast she would be sipping her fresh coffee from her JetBoil while we were still waiting on our PocketRocket to form simmering bubbles at the bottom of our titanium pot. It was clear that the JetBoil saved gas fuel over our PocketRocket, but until this fall I remained leery of JetBoil systems because of their size and weight.

Recently JetBoil introduced their compact and lightweight Stash model, which is supposedly '40% lighter' than other JetBoil systems. The advertised system weight (7.1 oz) matches the weight of our PocketRocket Deluxe paired with our similarly-sized titanium pot. I'm waiting on more product reviews, but for extended trips, the JetBoil Stash fuel savings would be a significant consideration for weight reduction.

 

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@TerryM - Wow! I love that anecdotal research! I have used a Pocket Rocket for about a decade and really loved its size, weight, and adaptability with cookware. I have only had to replace it once and got the exact same version that I started with, but hearing these kinds of stories makes me wonder if I'll switch it up the next time around. 

Thanks for sharing! 

At REI, we believe time outside is fundamental to a life well lived.

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@TerryM - Jetboils are a pleasure for their all-in-one convenient well made design and ease of use and can make sense for a couples/buddies cook system on short backpacking trips and for car trips/camping and other outdoor activates (eg climbing because you can hang the stove) but they are a bit overkill for solo backpacking.  We have an original 2003 JetBoil and 2019 Minimo and they are great for those uses (note: we do not climb).  We also have the 1.8L Jetboil pot used on a 3 person trip which I don't particularly recommend because the JetBoil pot stand gizmo is not secure enough and tends to catch on the pot's fins..that pot would probably would work well on a remote burner stove.

For solo 3 season backpacking only the new JetBoil "Stash" system makes sense weight wise although I have not tried it personally.  The chief advantage you get a competitively light weight one stop 800ml system that is very fuel efficient.  Casual tests indicated maybe as little as half the fuel compared to the PR2.  It does not have an integrated igniter which it should for the price imo.  And it might not be that great for melting snow - I have not seen a test - because the fuel efficiency comes partly from having a lower BTU burner.  It is apparently fast from room temp to boiling but pretty similar or slower to other stoves from near freezing to boiling.  Note: I have not tried melting snow in my JetBoils.  The Stash is not quite the elegant convenience fetish object that the traditional JetBoils are.  

Fuel efficiency makes the most sense for longer trips.  However the fixed sizes of canisters make fuel efficiency a bit of inconsistent advantage from a pure weight perspective.  The Stash system is light enough that I think you pretty much always break even or come out ahead.  With the other heavier JetBoil systems the advantage is less clear.

Generally, for solo use if you only heat water you can get away with a lighter stove and smaller pot.  My personal favorite is the Soto Amicus igniter model and for minimal use I have a Toaks 650ml light which together weigh about 5.5oz bare where the 800ml Stash apparently weighs about 7.5oz including a couple of giblets.  The Minimo is apparently 14.5oz with giblets. 

As far as I can tell the Amicus performs similarly or maybe slightly better than the PR2 except the Soto slightly cheaper and there is an igniter version.  The PR2 is definitely an improvement on the original Pocket Rocket.  The PR Deluxe is a bit overkill unless you have aspirations to actually cook...it has a regulator which makes a long slow burn more reliable and it is supposedly better in the wind.

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@OldGuyot truly grateful for the amount of effort and the insight you put into this! Extremely useful information that I will use in my quest to fine cuisine in the backcountry. Thank you so much for sharing this with all of us! 🙂

-Cyrus
0 Likes
Reply

Jetboil vs MSR PocketRocket?

@TerryM this is absolutely great information! Thank you for taking the time to share with us! 🙂

-Cyrus