
Imported.
Item 752295
| Specification |
| ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best use |
| ||||||||||
| Pedal design | |||||||||||
| SPD compatible | |||||||||||
| SPD-SL compatible | |||||||||||
| Time compatible | |||||||||||
| Look compatible | |||||||||||
| Crank Brothers compatible | |||||||||||
| Speedplay compatible | |||||||||||
| Weight | |||||||||||
| Material(s) |
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
Cons
Best Uses
Reviewed by 15 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
First off I only gave them 4 stars because Shimano makes the PD-M545 pedal which is essentially the same thing with a medal cage rather than the plastic, which would be more durable or so I would think. Other than that these pedals are 5 stars all the way and I have yet to see any issue with the plastic cage, nor do I think I will ever have one.
These are just my second pair of clipless pedals. My first pair where Welgo's (much like the Shimano M324 but way cheaper) and they were the type that had the flat pedal option on one side and the binding on the other side. I found this setup to be extremely aggravating on very technical terrain (if you're only riding bike paths or smooth trails it shouldn't be an issue). When I first tried these I was in heaven not having to think about what side the pedal was rotated on. The slightly recessed, angled binding and it's rotation on the spindle proved to be a huge advantage in getting into the pedal. These pedals are actually easier to ride on when not engaged into the binding with your cleat than the flat side of a pedal when wearing cleats. So my biggest advice is if your considering going clipless for some 'real' mtn biking go all in and get dual sided bindings because even with the 50/50 setup the clips on the bottom of your shoes will make it very hard to stay stable on the flat side of a pedal.
The cleats are the second thing I would give advice on. The Welgo's I mentioned above came with the same SPD clipless binding and a set of the SH56 cleats, which are multi directional. I am now wearing the SH51 cleats (which com ewiht these pedals) which are only engaged/disengaged in the outward twist motion. I would recommend getting the multi directional SH56 cleats if these are your first pedals.
I fell a lot to be honest, and the worst part was it was always when I was stopping (at slow speed)and the multi directional cleats will allow easy escaping from awkward falls. I've fallen way less on these pedals and have had a few very awkward positions I've had to escape from because of the one directional cleats.
So in conclusion these pedals are great and if your pondering these or a 50/50 (flat/clipless) setup (like the Shimano M324)go all in, you'll save yourself a lot of frustration. It is still a decent sized learning curve but persistence is key! I'll still find use for flat pedals but there is no doubt that being attached to your bike provides very noticeable benefits while pedaling AND just ripping down and over some sick trails!
Good luck!!!! Don't be afraid to laugh at yourself, it just makes riding that much more fun!
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
Pedals have a nice large platform so if you miss the initial step-in you can still stand on the platform or just mash on an uphill until you can re-adjust your foot. I ride alot of all mountain in the Bellingham area. Easy to get in and out of, have never had to adjust the tension. After about 10 rides I noticed the plastic frame had broken, don't remember rock bashing or any unusual fall. Probably better marketed to XC riders and commuters. At least I know I'll have no problem taking them back to REI.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
It took me about a half an hour with instructions in hand to figure out how to adjust the tension. once I had it figured out it was just too easy. I love the dual sided clip in!
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
Several people recommended pedals (and shoes) as the most important upgrade they made to their mountain bikes. It was good advice and I decided on the Shimano M424 pedals (and MT33L shoes.) These pedals offer enough platform for a brief ride without clips and easy entry with clips from either side. I wasn't sure if I'd transition well so this combination worked for me.
The good: Installation was a breeze and I was able to get nearly instant appreciation for the gain in power. Surprisingly, I was confident enough to ride after just 20 minutes practice. (This is not typical.) I noticed tremendous gains when climbing and I felt more able to power over/through terrain I would usually have dismounted for.
The bad: 1st timers, you will fall over. You need to train yourself to clip in and out. It eventually becomes second nature. Adjust your clips and teach yourself by leaning against a wall and clipping in and out. Then adjust your clips some more. Take your time to build confidence. Keep these clean. They're best in dry conditions.
Overall: I'm happy with these pedals so far. I feel like I have gains in power, energy and endurance.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
Excellent peddle very easy to use the platform really helps on touchy spots like steep hills. Lets you get moving before clipping in without slipping off.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
This is my first set of clipless pedals and I love them. They are surprisingly comfortable for short rides in regular shoes. I like the stability of the platform for tricky parts of a downhill trail when I unclip one foot. The release is pretty stiff out of the box and I recommend loosening it, it's quick and easy. Overall a good pedal and no complaints
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
I've used these pedals for the past 7 years on my mountain bikes and commuter bikes. These were the first clipless pedals I bought, so I wanted to ease in with something that would be forgiving if I missed a clip-in. That turned out not to be an issue - although remembering to clip out at stops was :D.
It's very nice on downhill MTB runs to have the extra support of the cage, and the cage also serves to protect the pedal. I've slammed these things hard on rocks, roots, and curbs and they've never broken. The only drawback is that they are not comfortable to ride with regular shoes for over 15 minutes. You can feel the clamp through the soles of your shoes, but it's OK for short rides.
Even after 7 years, these pedals are still going strong...and they'll be moving to my new MTB in a couple weeks. No need to buy new ones as these are still working fine. $10/year isn't a bad rate to use and abuse clipless pedals.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
I'm an All-Mountain style rider which basically means I do a bit of everything. Cross Country is mostly what I encounter around my home but I've also ridden black diamond runs on Mammoth Mountain. I use these on my Santa Cruz Heckler and they are much better than my old Crank Brothers Candy C pedals. The M424 SPDs are much more stable on technical and downhill terrain yet climbing with them is no problem and I recently used them on a XC race (Racers and Chasers). Unlike my old Crank Brothers they are adjustable so clipping and unclipping are much easier. If you're like me and enjoy all kinds of riding, these impressively versatile pedals are for you.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
OK I admit I've never ridden street or trail with clips before. I immediately loved the extra power stroke available on graveley up-hills. So, crazed with my new power, I didn't practice enough bailing out before I was beyond the point of no return on a real hill. When I actually think to kick-out, the clips work great! Unfortunately and after a dozed dumps into rock and cactus I want them to invent a clip that ejects me when I'm to stubborn to escape.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Shimano M424 SPD Pedals:
These are my first clipless pedals and the guy at REI recommended them he was right on. They were easy to adjust to after one fall, but I had to for the fun of it. Wow it is amazing how much power I have, can't believe I waited so long to upgrade the hills are no problem such efficiency and power I love these pedals. Love the fact that you can adjust the tension very smooth.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
* Intermediate markdowns may have been taken.
How are we doing? Give us feedback on this page.
REI Anniversary Sale May 17–27. Plus, members SAVE 20% on 1 full-price item with coupon code ANNV13. Details